Reviews |
Quick Review Camcorders : Panasonic PV-GS12
by Matt CullerPublished on October 01, 2004
The Panasonic PV-GS12 is a relatively low priced camera, retailing at around US $399.95, that comes with a 1/6th-inch 680K CCD. This small CCD size, as is growing common among low-priced consumer-level camcorders, leads to compromised color reproduction and accuracy in low lighting. The LCD screen located on the left side of the camera is a 2.5-inch color monitor that flips out and rotates from the camera body.
The adjustable black and white viewfinder cannot display the onscreen menu, making menu changes and manual control adjustments accessible only through the LCD screen. The easiest control to engage on the entire camera is the switch between the Automatic and Manual settings, which is simple. Manual controls are handled through the four-way controller, which grows tedious with long use.
With the CCD as small as it is, the color charts were unsatisfying in their results, with colors both uneven in the saturation patterns, and compromised throughout the charts -- most noticeably, the yellow and blue at 3000 lux, a light level considered high. The crispness of the image, and the transitions within the gray scale, are accurate and clean, although the jump between the lightest two bars is larger than the rest of the scale. The color charts at 60 and 15 lux are overly grayed, with dull tonal quality and a darkening of the image. The evenness of the color chart, however, is relatively improved, since the entire chart is darkened. Call that a partial victory for this camera. The overall crispness of the image is lowered, an expected side effect of diminished image quality. There are LED lights built into the front of the camera body, allowing the user of the Panasonic PV-GS12 the option of extra light, although the picture quality will likely become washed out.
The Panasonic PV-GS12 has a 20x optical zoom and a pointless 800x digital zoom, excessive to an extent I can’t even fathom. When digital zoom is engaged, the user of the Panasonic PV-GS12 will notice a drastic reduction in the image quality. The Manual control switch located on the left side of the camera body allows the user to engage the following manual features: zoom, focus, white balance, audio quality, shutter speed, and gain control. The control buttons located on the left side of the camera force the user into the laborious process of manual control where, even though the camera has many manual control options more expensive models lack, the only thing easily engaged is the LCD screen.
The following ports are available to the user of the Panasonic PV-GS12: A/V Out (doubles as an external mic port), USB, FireWire, SD Memory Card, Mini DV Tape. The port on the right side of the camera body, placed underneath the hand strap, is nearly impossible to use without first completely removing the strap from the camera body prior to use. Also, the lack of an analog input prevents analog-to-digital passthrough.
With its low price and 2.5-inch color LCD screen the Panasonic PV-GS12 could be a decent buy. There are preset picture effects, a widescreen mode, and an internal stereo mic, along with the external mic port. The controls have a fairly noticeable lag time, and are at times non-responsive, complicating the already internalized control menu. The image quality, although suffering in many situations, is still fairly strong in light of the price of the camera. The Panasonic PV-GS12 is capable of recording to Memory Card, MiniDV tape, and MPEG format. Finally, the 20x optical/800x digital zoom comes with the fairly standard 1/6th-inch 680K CCD. This camera would be best suited for those consumers looking for a point-and-shoot camcorder to use in well-lit situations.
| Panasonic PV-GS12 - THE BOTTOM LINE
Rating: 93.68 |
|
|
| Likes |
| - Manual Control
- 20x optical zoom - Audio options - Headphone port |
| Dislikes |
| - Bad ports (no analog input)
- No mic input - No accessory shoe |
Panasonic PV-GS12 Compared to the...
| Samsung
SCD303 Rating: 70.91 |
Canon
ZR90 Rating: 86.95 |
JVC
GR-D72 Rating: 70.91 |
Panasonic
PV-GS14 Rating: 102.70 |
Sony
DCR-HC20 Rating: 93.05 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Better | Better | Better | Better | Better |
| - 900x digital zoom
- S-Video, output - Mic input |
- 22x optical zoom
- Ports (analog to digital passthrough) - Cold accessory shoe - Handling |
- Low-light performance - Manual control
- 700x digital zoom - Ports (analog to digital passthrough) - Mic input |
- 22x optical zoom
- Mic input - S-Video output |
- Ease of use
- Better LCD screen - Automatic control - Mic input - LANC jack - Cold accessory shoe |
| Equal | Equal | Equal | Equal | Equal |
| - CCD size
- Still card media - No accessory shoe - No analog to digital passthrough -20x optical zoom |
- No mic input
- Headphone input - CCD specs - Cold accessory shoe - Still media - No mic input |
- CCD size, pixel count - Still media (SD/MM card)
|
- 1/6" CCD, pixel count - Headphone jack
- Manual Control - Still options |
- 1/6 inch CCD
- No analog to digital passthrough |
| Worse | Worse | Worse | Worse | Worse |
| - No headphone jack
- No accessory shoe - Manual control - Bottom loading - Fewer still options - Low light performance |
- 440x digital zoom
- Color viewfinder - Low light performance - Manual control |
- 16x optical zoom
- 700x digital zoom - No headphone input - Manual control |
- Color viewfinder | - 10x optical zoom
- 120x digital zoom - No headphone |





